I noticed a lot of reactions against Islam after the dems won the congressional and senatorial seats with a significant trend on Muslim leaders being elected.
There have been criticism of the Sharia law and Islamist and sometimes using the latter term as deregatory.
So let us clarify here to shed insight as to what Sharia Law is and what Islamist and other related terminology to it realy is.
First the term Islamist. The term is accurately alluded to individuals or groups advocating for Islam elements in a state’s political system. It can vary from selected Islam elements being part of a wider governing politics or even the complete spectrum of Islam. The political ideology advocated by Islamist is Islamism.
Islamism is a political ideology aiming to restructure existing political systems to incorportate parts of Islam elements or the whole Islam religion into the political structure. The wider aim is to return to a form of government during the 7th century Islam which is not Islamism but Islamic.
Islamic is a term to describe anything related to Islam and the 7th century Islamic governance is not Islamism. Islamism is a political ideology that was born in the 19 century aiming to revive governance and political structure based from the 7th century Islam state. The 7th century Islamic state did not aim to revive past Islamic state because they the first, and philosophically, the first Islamic state of the 7th century is not the same as Islamism based states of today.
Islam by itself is a religion founded in the 7th century in remote region in the ancient middle east, thrived and flourished to have its own political structure, governance, and economy based on Islam principles.
While there is a timeline were we can identify Islamic states from 7th century which are not Islamism based, there is also timeline where Islamism based states came into existence and are Islamic.
Sharia law is part of Islamic states and is a system of law much like the laws we have in a democratic states like the US and Phillipines. Think of civil law and criminal law, their counterpart in states where governance and political structure revolves around the Islam religion is Sharia Law.
Contrary to popular belief, understanding and implementation of Sharia law is not uniform unversally across Islamic states. For example, while there exist Islamic states that cruelly punishes homosexuality and prostitution, there are also Islamic states which tolerated it and imposed less severe punishments in the form of penalties. The mighty Ottoman empire which is known to be the most just Muslim state compared to others is known to tolerate homosexulity and prostitution. In fact, some of the Ottoman Caliphates (God’s representative on Earth) were homosexuals while brothels were allowd to exist to some extent. Oh yes, God gave the victory to the Ottoman empire where homosexuality is embedded in their ancient culture, over the defeat of Constantinople.
Most people don’t know that Saul who hated David and Jonathan who loves David were both gays. David later indulges on the carnality of the sexual lust over women and he was still God’s favorite.
In Iran which is majority Shia, they have a temporary marriages called Mut’ah which by the western standards is viewed as prostitution but is allowed under their Sharia law.
Digressing a bit from the main topic, sexuality in Islam is not shunned unlike in Christianity. Islam understood that sexuality is tied to the basic needs of humans much like how security and economic stability is needed. Mut’ah was allowed in the early Islam as Muslim warriors were at some wars far away from their wives and there were women who were in need of economic leverage that were nearby. There is an ongoing debate about this and the Sunni’s claim that it was later abrogated but the Shia believes it is still allowed. I am on the side of the Shia on this although I am a Sunni.
In the Philippines, the creation of the Bangsamoro Autnonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao (BARMM) is Islamic because it has elements related to Islam, it has individuals and groups that are Islamist but there are also non-islamists and it follows that it also has elements of Islamism but not all of BARMM is Islamist.
Sharia law exist in BARMM and only applies to Muslims and the Sharia Law there is under the scope of the wider civil and criminal law of the Philippines.
In the US, maybe Muslims groups someday will lobby for Sharia law but in no way will it supercede US laws and apply to non-Muslims. The existence of Sharia law is justified when a community seeks its implementation and this is aligned with the philosophy of law and justice. Sharia law is justice, much like how the western laws are justice.
The reason why people fear it is because it is an identity of a religion that people are not subscribing to.
US being a diverse population and ruled by a democratic principles, Sharia law can exist to give the justice the Muslim minorities seek for their communities without oppressing the non-muslims in the US.
On the other hand, there is stigma in the term Islamic, Islamist, and Islamism, because of the 9-11 attacks and the war on terror that followed and the US-Israel war against Iran recently.
Not all Muslims are enemies of the state. The ones that became the villains during the 9-11 and the war in terror are extremist Muslims indocrinated with hate from teachings of the Wahabist sect that originated in Saudi Arabia. Those that are not wahabist but spread terror are simply because they manifested their political ideals against the west and ended deciding to take militant and violent actions just like any state adversary will do.
Even in ancient China, there was a time where in a specific dynasty it was forbidden for 3 Muslims to walk together and is a crime because of the warfare capabilities of Muslims and were seen as threats to the state.
In the Holy Quran, we Muslims are instructed to respect and not harm the people of the book. These are Jews and Christians. There was also a strict instruction but I forgot already if it is in the Holy Quran or the Hadiths where we are instructed to not harm non-Muslims by the beloved prophet (SAW) himself.
In my view, if a country is a Muslim majority, I’d advocate for an Islamic political government but with protection of the minorities to preempt injustice and oppression. If a country is not a Muslim majority then I’d advocate for democracy so that all enjoys the same freedom. For me, it is a matter of utility, what benefits the majority.
This site will hold short thoughts, daily observations, technical discoveries, project progress, and records that do not require a full article.